Who was Elizabeth Mary CUMMINGS?
When she married my great-grandfather Samuel HOUGHTON in April 1895, Elizabeth Mary CUMMINGS was a 20 year old spinster and she gave her father’s name as George CUMMINGS (labourer). The witnesses were James MARTEN and Isabella CUMMINGS. Her age corresponds with that in the 1901 census (25), in which her place of birth was given as Liverpool. After a lot of searching, however, I had been unable to find any record of the birth of an Elizabeth Mary CUMMINGS on or around 1875 so dropped this line of enquiry to pursue other ancestors. The breakthrough came in collaboration with a couple of contacts I later made through the GenesReunited website.
The first was John MADDOCK, whose g-grandfather Henry MADDOCK was married to an Agnes CUMMINGS. John discovered references to my Houghtons in documents relating to Henry’s death. Amongst the mourners at Henry’s funeral were my g-grandfather Samuel HOUGHTON, listed as being his nephew and my grandfather, Samuel Henry HOUGHTON and his sister Phyllis HOUGHTON who were said to be his grandchildren. The informant on Henry’s death certificate was Elizabeth HOUGHTON, niece, of 26 Foster St, Widnes. He also knew from Agnes’ marriage certificate that her father was a baker called Andrew CUMMINGS. John subsequently found Andrew in the 1871 census, one of 219 prisoners in the main Bridewell on Dale Street, Liverpool.
1871 Census (Main Bridewell, Dale Street, Liverpool)
Andrew CUMMINGS, prisoner, married, 46, baker, b. Scotland
Lynn RUSSELL, who is related to me through my grandfather’s sister Ivy, had also been researching her HOUGHTON line and she joined the search finding what we believe to be Elizabeth’s birth certificate under the name BOYLE. The certificate details are:
Elizabeth Mary BOYLE, born 9th October 1874 at 133 Mann St, Toxteth Park. Father: George BOYLE; Occupation, Carter. Mother; Ann Jane BOYLE, formerly CUMMINGS.
In the 1881 census, Henry and Agnes were living with their 6 year old niece, Elizabeth BOYL, born in Liverpool:
1881 Census (7 Minto St, West Derby, Liverpool)
Henry MADDOCK, 29, Cotton porter, b. Everton, Liverpool
Agnes MADDOCK, 29, b. Edinburgh
* Elizabeth BOYL, niece, 6, b. Liverpool
In 1891, Henry and Agnes now have a 16 year old Elizabeth MADDOCK (born in Liverpool) living with them as their daughter:
1891 Census (37 James St, Widnes)
Henry MADDOCK, 39, Fitter, b. Liverpool
Agnes MADDOCK, 39, b. Scotland
* Elizabeth MADDOCK, daughter, 16, b. Liverpool
* We believe that these are the same person; i.e. our Elizabeth Mary BOYLE.
Further confirmation of a link between the HOUGHTON and MADDOCK families comes from the observation that on her marriage certificate in 1928, Ivy HOUGHTON gave her address as 26 Foster St, the same as that given by Elizabeth HOUGHTON on Henry MADDOCK’s death certificate in 1926. [Other addresses in Widnes have also accommodated both MADDOCKs and HOUGHTONs; e.g. 12 Cliffe St – Jessie HOUGHTON was born there in 1900 and Henry & Agnes MADDOCK lived there with son John in 1901; 6 Foster St – Phyllis and Ivy HOUGHTON were born there (1904 and 1908 respectively) and John MADDOCK gave the same address on his marriage certificate in 1914].
We then started to search the censuses for CUMMINGS (and various similar spellings) to try and see if we can build up a picture of the family over the decades:
1861 Census (3 Court, Lime Kiln Lane, Vauxhall, Liverpool)
Andrew CUMMING, 34, Baker, b. Scotland
Elizabeth CUMMING, wife, 35, b. Scotland
** Ann J. CUMMING, dau, 8, scholar, b. Scotland
Elizabeth CUMMING, dau, 3, scholar, b. Liverpool
** Elizabeth Mary BOYLE”s mother.
As we know, Andrew was in Dale St bridewell on the day of the 1871 census so where were the rest of the family?
There is an Elizabeth CUMMINS in Toxteth workhouse who could be our Elizabeth:
1871 Census (Toxteth Park workhouse)
Elizabeth CUMMINS, pauper, mar, 44, general servant, b. Scotland
Andrew’s daughter Elizabeth could be with her younger brother in Blair St, Toxteth (they are the only persons listed in the household):
1871 Census (16 house 4 court, Blair St, Toxteth, Liverpool)
Elizabeth CUMMINGS, dau, 13, scholar, b. Liverpool
Andrew CUMMINGS, son, 10, scholar, b. Liverpool
There is an Ann CUMMINGS working as a domestic servant in Birkenhead:
1871 Census (8 Balls Road, Birkenhead)
Ann CUMMINGS, servant, unm, 20, domestic servant, b. Scotland
In 1881, Ann BOYLE is boarding with a George THRELFALL, along with her daughter Agnes, while her father Andrew CUMMINGS is reunited with his wife in Bootle:
1881 Census (5 court 8 house, Clive St, Toxteth Park, Liverpool)
George THRELFALL, head, mar, 40, Plasterer’s labourer, b. Liverpool
George CAVANAGH, boarder, Unm, 44, House painter, b. Liverpool
Ann J. BOYLE, boarder, mar, 27, Charwoman, b. Scotland
Agnes A. BOYLE, dau of Ann Boyle, 1 month, b. Liverpool.
1881 Census (10 Pleasant View, Bootle)
Catherine LYNCH, head, widow, 42, Charwoman, b. Ireland
James LYNCH, son, Unm, 19, Bricklayer, b. Liverpool
Catherine McCOURT, visitor, Unm, 22, Domestic servant, b. Bootle
Andrew CUMMINS, boarder, mar, 54, Baker, b. Scotland
Elizabeth CUMMINS, boarder, mar, 54, b. Scotland
Thomas DEMPSEY, lodger, Unm, 23, General labourer, b. Liverpool
John BURNS, lodger, Unm, 38, Tailor, b. Liverpool
In 1891, Andrew and Elizabeth are still together and are now living in Seaforth, with their son Andrew and his wife Catherine:
1891 Census (18 Beaumaris Street, Litherland, Seaforth)
Andrew CUMMINS, head, mar, 29, labourer at docks, b. Liverpool
Elizabeth CUMMINS, wife, mar, 27, b. Bootle
Esther CUMMINS, dau, 2, b. Seaforth
Andrew CUMMINS, father, mar, 64, Baker, b. Scotland
Elizth CUMMINS, mother, mar, 65, b. Scotland
Elizabeth died before the 1901 census as Andrew is now a widower:
1901 Census (17 Conway, Street, Seaforth)
Andrew CUMMINS, head, widower, 74, ship’s(?) watchman, b. Scotland
Eliz. McINTOSH, dau, widow, 34, b. Liverpool
Georgina THRELFALL, grand-dau, single, 17, general servant, b. Liverpool
Andrew CUMMINS, head, mar, 39, general labourer, b. Liverpool
Catherine CUMMINS, wife, mar, 36, dressmaker, own account/at home, b. Bootle
Esther CUMMINS, dau, 12, b. Seaforth
Alfred J. CUMMINS, son, 9, b. Seaforth
Andrew CUMMINS, son, 1, b. Seaforth
~ 1852 (Scotland) – Andrew & Elizabeth’s daughter, Agnes, is born
~ 1853 (Scotland) – Andrew & Elizabeth’s daughter, Ann J. , is born
~ 1853-1858 – Andrew & Elizabeth move from Edinburgh to Liverpool
~ 1858 (Liverpool) – Andrew & Elizabeth’s daughter Elizabeth, is born
~ 1862 (Liverpool) – Andrew & Elizabeth’s son, Andrew, is born
~ 1871 (Liverpool) – Andrew is in the bridewell.
~ 1874 (Liverpool) – Ann J. CUMMINGS/BOYLE’s daughter, Elizabeth Mary BOYLE, is born
~ 1881 (Liverpool) – Elizabeth (BOYL)/BOYLE is living with her aunt & uncle, Agnes & Henry MADDOCK
~ 1891 (Liverpool) – Elizabeth (BOYLE)/MADDOCK is living as the daughter of Agnes & Henry MADDOCK
~ 1895 (Widnes) – Elizabeth Mary (BOYLE/MADDOCK)/CUMMINGS marries Samuel HOUGHTON
In addition to the above:
– Elizabeth BOYL/MADDOCK gave birth to John MADDOCK in Whiston Workhouse (1892). There is no father on the birth certificate. In the following census, John MADDOCK is living with Agnes and Henry MADDOCK as their son.
– In the 1881 census, Ann J. BOYLE (35) is boarding in the house of George THRELFALL. She has a one month old daughter, Agnes A. BOYLE.
– In 1891, Ann J THRELFALL is a widow, boarding with her daughters Georgina (age 9) and Winifred (age 2). Georgina’s birth certificate confirms that her father is George THRELFALL and her mother is Ann J THRELFALL, formerly CUMMINGS.
– The 1901 census has Georgina THRELFALL as the granddaughter of Andrew CUMMINS (age 74) in Seaforth. His daughter Elizabeth McINTOSH (a widow, age 44) is there also. Living next door is Andrew’s son and his family.
Do we know the answer to the original question, who was Elizabeth Mary CUMMINGS?
* She was the daughter of Ann Jane CUMMINGS and George BOYLE. Her birth certificate (above) gives her name as Elizabeth Mary BOYLE and that her mother was Ann Jane BOYLE, formerly CUMMINGS but we have no evidence that Ann and George were ever married.
* In 1881, we think that she was the Elizabeth BOYL, staying with Agnes and Henry MADDOCK as their niece.
* In the 1891 census she appears to be Elizabeth MADDOCK, Agnes and Henry MADDOCK’s daughter.
* A year later Elizabeth MADDOCK has an illegitimate son, John MADDOCK. (In the 1901 census, it seems that John is being raised as Agnes and Henry’s son).
* In 1895, as Elizabeth Mary CUMMINGS, she marries Samuel HOUGHTON.
* Elizabeth & Samuel have ten children; Elizabeth Mary HOUGHTON dies in 1944 at the age of 69.
The best theory that we can come up with that fits the above evidence is that Ann Jane CUMMINGS and George BOYLE had a daughter, Elizabeth Mary, but they don’t actually marry (explaining why we haven’t been able to find a marriage certificate). George disappears off the scene and Elizabeth goes to live with her mother’s sister Agnes and her husband Henry MADDOCK, where they call her their niece (1871 census) and then later their daughter (1881 census), when she is known as Elizabeth MADDOCK. Meanwhile, her mother Ann, with daughter Agnes A., boards with and then marries George THRELFALL. Elizabeth later has an illegitimate son, John, who is also brought up by Agnes and Henry MADDOCK as their son. When she marries Samuel HOUGHTON, Elizabeth uses her mother’s maiden name CUMMINGS.
Considerable effort (not just on my part) has gone into trying to find out who George BOYLE was and why he disappeared off the scene. In particular, where was he at the time of the 1881 census? I have dedicated a separate page detailing our efforts to identify George BOYLE.
We already know that Andrew and Elizabeth CUMMINGS and at least two of their children, Ann and Agnes, were born in Scotland (Agnes in Edinburgh) from the English censuses so it’s time to explore this side of the story.
Once again I would liken to thank Lynn, John, Pat and Liz for doing much of the hard detective work and providing me with details of the censuses and other documents they obtained.
1851 Census (Scotland – 53 Regent Arch, Edinburgh)
Andrew COMMONS, head, marr, 24, Baker journeyman, Berwickshire Swinton?
Elizabeth COMMONS, wife, marr, 25, Edinburgh St Cuthberts
Isabella COMMONS, dau, 2, Berwickshire Dunse
This is the first clue we’ve had as to Andrew’s birthplace, although having said that, the actual census image was difficult to interpret and Swinton could equally be read as Lunton or Lanton.
We have Andrew’s marriage record which states that he was a Baker of Greenside Row and that he married Elizabeth LISTER, daughter of William LISTER, Shoemaker in Edinburgh in 1848.
Andrew and Elizabeth’s children have also been identified from various records. In 1861, Andrew and Elizabeth’s eldest daughters, Isabella and Agnes, are in Edinburgh with their grandfather William LISTER:
1861 Census (Scotland – 8 Carnegie Street, St Cuthberts, Edinburgh)
William LISTER, hear, marr, 62
Isabella LISTER, wife, marr, 61
Jane LISTER, dau, 31
Samuel LISTER, son, 28
Isabella COMMON, grand-dau, 12, scholar, Dunse Berwickshire
Agnes COMMON, grand-dau, 9, scholar, Edinburgh
Ann Jane b. circa 1854 in Scotland (from 1871 census)
William b. 1855 in Duns, Berwickshire
Elizabeth b. circa 1858 in Liverpool
Andrew b. circa 1862 in Liverpool
Unfortunately, Andrew was not with his parents for the 1841 census and the likeliest candidate we could find was in Cockburnspath, which is some 20 km to the north of Dunse:
1841 Census (Scotland – Co’path Tower Stable, Cockburnspath)
Andrew CUMMING, 14, Ag. Lab.
Going by his age in the censuses, Andrew would have been born around 1826/7 and the closest match we have found is the birth of an Andrew COMMON who is the son of William COMMON and Agnes JOHNSON, born March 8th and baptised March 25th 1827 in Swinton. The only other corroborating evidence that we have for William and Agnes being Andrew’s parents is that Andrew and Elizabeth’s children names appear to follow traditional naming conventions, i.e.
1st son named after father’s father
2nd son named after mother’s father
3rd son named after father
1st daughter named after mother’s mother
2nd daughter named after father’s mother
3rd daughter named after mother
We have also found William, Agnes and their children in the Scottish censuses (1841 – 1871)
1871 Census (Scotland – Swinton Square, Swinton)
William COMMON, head, marr, 71, Hedger, Swinton, Berwickshire
Agnes COMMON, wife, marr, 68, Foggo, Berwickshire
Peter COMMON, son, unmarr, 29, labourer, Dunse, Berwickshire
1861 Census (Scotland – Berrywell Cottage, Dunse)
William COMMON, head, marr, 61, Hedger, Swinton, Berwickshire
Agnes COMMON, wife, marr, 58, Fogo, Berwickshire
Peter COMMON, son, 16, scholar, Dunse, Berwickshire
1851 Census (Scotland – Cottage at Berrywell, Dunse)
William COMMON, head, marr, 51, Hedger, Swinton, Berwickshire
Agnes COMMON, wife, marr, 48, Fogo, Berwickshire
John COMMON, son, unmarr, 19, labourer, ?
William COMMON, son, unmarr, 17, labourer, Swinton, Berwickshire
Alison COMMON, dau, unmarr, 15, scholar, Swinton, Berwickshire
James COMMON, son, unmarr, 13, scholar, Swinton, Berwickshire
Peter COMMON, son, unmarr, 6, scholar, Dunse Berwickshire
1841 Census (Scotland – Bridge End, Swinton)
William COMMON, 40, Hedger
Agnes COMMON, 35
Janet COMMON, 12
John COMMON, 10
Alison COMMON, 5
James COMMON, 3
Peter COMMON, 9 months
From various sources, we have discovered that:
William COMMON was born in Swinton in 1799 and died in Swinton in 1873; his parents were Andrew COMMON, hedger, and Janet KER (sometimes spelt KERR). His wife Agnes was born in Fogo in 1802 and died in Swinton in 1891; her parents were John JOHNSTON and Isabella HUME. William and Agnes were married in 1824 in Swinton.
William’s father Andrew married Janet KER in 1795 in Swinton and before that he was married to Janet DODS in 1763.
Andrew had 5 children with Janet DODS:
Rachel, born 1764 in Langton
Rachel, born 1771 in Eccles
Andrew, born 1772 in Eccles
Anne, born 1775 in Eccles
Peter, born 1777 in Eccles
Andrew and Janet’s sons, Andrew and Peter, are remembered in a Latin inscription on a gravestone in the Swinton parish church graveyard. The light was fading as I was trying to record it so to the best of my ability, the inscription reads:
RELIQUIAE EXIMII ADOLESCENTIS
QUI 2 SEPTEMBRIS AD 1792
AE- ATIS SUAE 19 ANNO ANIMAM
ETIAM PETRI CUMMING QUI
QUAM SUI FRATER STUDIA
HAUD MINUS SUBLIMIORA
PETEBAT DUM DEGEBAT IN TERRIS
SED HIC QUOQUE NATO FUNCTUS
MATURE(I)AM IN PACE ANCURA
QUIEVIT QUINDECIMO ANTE
MALAS CALENDAS ANNO
AETATIS SUAE VICE SINO
PRIMO ET REDEMPTI O(I?) RIS
ET NONAGESIMO OCTAVO (1798)
Which translates as (thank you Ed!):
Here lie the remains of the most excellent young man Andrew Cumming, student
of philosophy, who on 2nd September 1792 fell ill at the age of 19 years.
Also we pray for Peter Cumming who, like his brother, strove to study to no
lesser height as long as he lived on Earth, but in the same way did he also
hasten to rest in peace without pain before he had reached the age of 15
years, but not without first conquering evil and finding redemption. 1798
Andrew had another son with Janet KER – Andrew, born in 1797. He married Isabellla JOHNSTON, the sister of his brother’s wife Agnes JOHNSTON in 1822. He was a hedger and forester and an Elder of the Free Church of Scotland. We have details of Andrew and Isabella’s children and to make things easier to follow I have prepared a chart (JPG image) that shows the relationships (click image for larger version).